Tobacco’s ESG pretentions all smoke and no fire
Back
Article Type
Press Releases
Published
October 30, 2023
Read time
5 mins
Author
Miranda Beacham
Share

 

As another Stoptober draws to a close, Miranda Beacham, Head of ESG for equities and multi-asset at Aegon Asset Management, contends that tobacco companies have no place in sustainable funds, despite the industry’s ESG pretentions.

 

Stoptober was launched by the Department of Health in England in 2012, when it challenged people to go smoke free – with support – for 28 days. It has been gathering steam ever since and is part of the international movement to stop smoking.

 

The reasons for these initiatives are clear. According to the World Health Organization, smoking kills 8 million people per year, including 1.3 million non-smokers who are inhaling second-hand smoke1.  Meanwhile, a study carried out by Action for Smoking and Health (ASH) estimates that smoking costs the economy in England £17bn per year, £2.4bn of which lands on the NHS, which is already stretched thinly.2

 

Despite these statistics, there is a concerning view – largely propagated by the industry itself – that tobacco companies may be developing strong ESG credentials. Does that mean they deserve a place in sustainable funds? We don’t think so.

 

Bold claims

The tobacco industry has always boasted marketing savvy. Those old enough will remember the advertisements in the 1950s that showcased the ‘health benefits’ of smoking and the celebrity endorsements and sports sponsorships that followed.

 

Well, earlier this year, the CEO of Philip Morris made a bold claim that his company was on its way to becoming an ESG stock3. How can that be? In theory, it’s because the company is pivoting away from cigarettes and towards vaping products, which now account for around one third of revenues. But are these new products the future of “sustainable” smoking? The industry itself seems conflicted on the answer.

 

In the past few years there have been a number of studies, from the likes of King’s College London, on the health impacts of vaping. These have shown that vaping is indeed safer than smoking – but with cigarettes killing up to half of the smokers who fail to quit, that was never an especially high hurdle. There is, in particular, a lot of concern over the use of vaping by teenagers. Rather than an aid to stop smoking, critics claim it is simply replacing one addiction with another. 

 

The CEO of British American Tobacco has subsequently asked for a greater degree of regulation around vaping. This may seem unexpected; however, it makes commercial sense to give the industry greater certainty in the face of growing opposition.

 

Fresh backlash

A number of countries have already banned the sale of flavoured vaping devices, observing that they have been widely targeted at children. In fact, in April 2023, Juul reached a settlement of $462million with a number of states in the US for aggressively doing just that – marketing its devices to children. Additionally, Argentina, Thailand and India have completely banned e-cigarettes altogether for health reasons and the possibility of luring young people into an addiction.

 

While these actions focus attention only on the health impact of these devices, which we may not fully understand yet, there are also numerous concerns over the environmental impact of vaping – particularly with single-use devices.

 

Moreover, there is also a very live debate over engagement with, or divestment from, “dirty” industries. There are merits in both approaches and a lot depends on the industry itself and its ability to change. Given the concerns outlined above, we believe tobacco has a long road to travel before it can be considered as having a net positive impact on global society.

 

Ultimately, however, it is simply not possible for some industries to change to an extent that would meet the sustainable standards required by funds that are interested in outcomes for health and the environment, so you will not be finding any tobacco companies in any of our Sustainability-themed funds for the foreseeable future.

 

1 https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/tobacco#:~:text=Around%2080%25%20of%20the%20world's,men%20and%207.8%25%20of%20women.

2https://ash.org.uk/media-centre/news/press-releases/14bn-a-year-up-in-smoke-economic-toll-of-smoking-in-england-revealed#:~:text=The%20overall%20cost%20of%20smoking,the%20NHS%20and%20social%20care.

3https://www.ft.com/content/99901b48-8c58-407d-af90-5fab9a883ae0

 

-Ends-

 

Notes for the editor

 

About Aegon Asset Management

 

Aegon Asset Management is an active global investor. Our 375 investment professionals manage and advise on assets of €294 ($321/£253) billion (as of June 30, 2023) for a global client-base of pension plans, public funds, insurance companies, banks, wealth managers, family offices and foundations.

 

We organize our investment capabilities around four focused investment platforms where we have extensive asset-class expertise: Fixed Income, Real Assets, Equities and Multi-Asset & Solutions. Each platform has dedicated teams, organized globally and committed to maximizing their specialist areas. These platforms and the Fiduciary business are supported by a team dedicated to responsible investing. 

 

By organizing our investment teams globally, we work to harness our expertise and research resources across regional boundaries. We believe this enhances our performance potential and helps provide better investment outcomes for clients.

 

Across platforms, we share a common belief in fundamental, research-driven active management, underpinned by effective risk management and a commitment to responsible investment. Our investment platforms have the flexibility to organize their resources and processes to best suit their area of focus.

 

We are a global business: Our 1,200 employees work across Europe, the Americas and Asia. We invest globally and serve clients locally.

 

For more information about Aegon Asset Management, visit www.aegonam.com

 

This document is for use by professional journalists. Its content is written for use in trade and retail publications. 

Past performance does not predict future returns. Outcomes, including the payment of income, are not guaranteed. 

 

Opinions and/or example trades/securities represent our understanding of markets both current and historical and are used to promote Aegon Asset Management's investment management capabilities: they are not investment recommendations, research or advice. Sources used are deemed reliable by Aegon Asset Management at the time of writing. Please note that this marketing is not prepared in accordance with legal requirements designed to promote the independence of investment research, and is not subject to any prohibition on dealing by Aegon Asset Management or its employees ahead of its publication. 

 

All data is sourced to Aegon Asset Management unless otherwise stated. The document is accurate at the time of writing but is subject to change without notice. Data attributed to a third party (“3rd Party Data”) is proprietary to that third party and/or other suppliers (the “Data Owner”) and is used by Aegon Asset Management under licence.  3rd Party Data: (i) may not be copied or distributed; and (ii) is not warranted to be accurate, complete or timely.  None of the Data Owner, Aegon Asset Management or any other person connected to, or from whom Aegon Asset Management sources, 3rd Party Data is liable for any losses or liabilities arising from use of 3rd Party Data. 

 

This document is issued by Aegon Asset Management UK plc in the United Kingdom and is issued by Aegon Investment Management B.V. in the European Union and European Economic Area. Aegon Asset Management NL is a trading name of Aegon Investment Management B.V. 

 

Aegon Asset Management UK plc is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Aegon Investment Management B.V. is authorised and regulated by the Netherlands Authority for the Financial Markets.  

 

AdTrax Code 6052797.2. 

Exp: 23.10.24

Author

Miranda Beacham
Head of UK Responsible Investment
Miranda Beacham is Head of Responsible Investment at AAM UK.  Her role involves overseeing the environmental, social and governance research process for ethical and sustainable funds as well as overseeing the stewardship activities, supporting the ESG integration processes and further research in ESG issues for investments across Aegon AM UK.
View profile